Did homers trojan war exist

did homers trojan war exist Best answer: first of all let me tell you that the trojan war is a greek myth which describes a civil war it is not a war between greece and troy but a war between achaeans (a greek tribe) and trojans (an other greek tribe)in the myth the trojans are descried as greeks.

The trojan war glows with a dark fire at the dawn of time as the unsurpassable model for all the wars that were to come an extraordinary phenomenon must have an extraordinary cause did homer think so. The great works of the greek poet homer, the odyssey and the iliad, tell of a war between the greeks and the city of ilium, which was also called troy after the region in which it was located. The trojan war: history or bricolage 1 susan sherratt the trojan war motif, which forms the essential background to the iliad and the odyssey and also to many other greek epics (such as those which form part of the so-called epic cycle, numerous literary epics, as well as attic tragedy and much historical literature), has loomed largely and more or less continuously for something like two and. There is ample evidence to show that a trojan war did occur, and that homer did look upon the site as his descriptions of the landscape are so accurate however the myths surrounding the war and its events are open to speculation and any evidence pieced together on these would be circumstantial. The trojan war - a more or less mythical event - was a 10-year siege of the city of troy by a coalition of greeks, its purpose to restore helen to her spartan husband, menelaus.

did homers trojan war exist Best answer: first of all let me tell you that the trojan war is a greek myth which describes a civil war it is not a war between greece and troy but a war between achaeans (a greek tribe) and trojans (an other greek tribe)in the myth the trojans are descried as greeks.

Yes there is evidence he did exist and that he was the one who wrote the odyssey and iliad based on legends of siege of the city of troy 400 years before he (homer) was born homer lived a long time before it was possible to objectively trace evidence of authorship of the iliad and the odyssey so there is controversy that it was him. We know of the trojan war from various greek legends, plays and poems, with homer much the most important some of these contradict homer on important points, so it's probably not all derived from homer and then adapted. The story of the trojan horse is well-known first mentioned in the odyssey, it describes how greek soldiers were able to take the city of troy after a fruitless ten-year siege by hiding in a giant horse supposedly left as an offering to the goddess athena but was it just a myth probably, says. The story of the trojan war—the bronze age conflict between the kingdoms of troy and mycenaean greece-straddles the history and mythology of ancient greece and inspired the greatest writers of.

Furthermore, according to hittite records, there were political and military tensions around troy precisely during the thirteenth and early twelfth centuries bc--the supposed time of homer's trojan war. Was the trojan war a historical event scholars are uncertain about the historical details of the trojan war there is evidence that a city named troy did exist and that it was ransacked and destroyed by the greeks, but the proportions of the battle and some of the events described may have been elaborated by greek authors. The most recent excavations have determined that troy, now covering about seventy-five acres, is about fifteen times larger than formerly thought. As for the war in homer's iliad being real or not - i tend to believe it was what you need is to go get the book - in search of the trojan war by michael wood from the library or you can rent the dvds by the same name from the library most likely.

Early in the iliad, homer's epic poem about the legendary trojan war, there occurs a famous digression known as the catalogue of ships, which names all the greek leaders and contingents who came. And finally that some sort of a ―trojan war‖ did take place it was probably either homer's metaphor for an earthquake as for the trojan horse or a battering ram a number of the greek warriors. The trojan horse is a classic tale set during the trojan war in the story the greeks build a large wooden horse and hide inside it, the trojans accept the horse as a victory trophy and pull it into the city. Did homer's trojan war exist the trojan war, the event depicted in homer's iliad, was the most popular subject in greek drama and told its story elaborately to next generations according to homer, the war started because helen, the most beautiful greek woman and wife of a greek king, menelaus, decided to leave her husband and ran away with. The story of the ancient city of troy is a great one, however many people believed it didn't exist and that homers iliad, the story of the trojan war was just some story this has since been proved untrue as the city of troy was discovered, and the pieces of this amazing puzzle have fallen together.

Did homers trojan war exist

Homer's style, whoever he was, falls more in the category of minstrel poet or balladeer, as opposed to a cultivated poet who is the product of a fervent literary moment, such as a virgil or a. Name troy - did it really exist questions 1 according to homer, how long did the trojan war last a about 30 years b about 20 years c about 15 years. The trojan war, the event depicted in homer's iliad, was the most popular subject in greek drama and told its story elaborately to next generations.

From existing oral tradition, audiences knew the tales of the long siege, the duels outside the city walls, and the trick that finally won the war in the end, the city was burned to the ground. The trojan war part epic, part cautionary tale, we know the story of troy and its famous war from ancient poets like homer and virgil , who transcribed the narrative in antiquity homer's account, known as the iliad , was codified in the eighth-century bce from preexisting oral tradition s. But, surprisingly, you won't find any of that in the iliad, homer's great epic poem about the war for troy for reasons that scholars still debate today, the iliad ends with the funeral of the trojan prince hector, and never gets to the end of the war. The greatest warrior in the achaian army the iliad is about the trojan war, but it is primarily about the war as it is affected by achilles' wrath, or angerachilles is the main character, and his inaction, or withdrawal from the fighting, is crucial to the plot.

For example, the mycenean helmet made of boars' tusks did not exist in homer's time, and had been forgotten by the putative time of the trojan war, but it did exist at the time the myceneans administered crete after the explosion of thera, two to four hundred years before the probable date of the trojan war (the dating of this era is very. Films based on the trojan war include helen of troy (1956), the trojan horse (1961) and troy (2004) the war has also been featured in many books, television series, and other creative works the war has also been featured in many books, television series, and other creative works. The event is referred to in homer's odyssey in the greek tradition, the horse is called the wooden horse pausanias, a greek traveller and geographer of the 2nd century ad, theorized that the trojan horse was a gigantic battering ram whose form reminded of a horse. In the iliad homer writes about half way through the trojan war, describing the origins of the war, how helen ran away from her husband, the king of sparta, with the prince of troy in it homer also writes about the greek heroes, such as achilles and ajax, he also writes about some of the trojan heroes such as hector.

did homers trojan war exist Best answer: first of all let me tell you that the trojan war is a greek myth which describes a civil war it is not a war between greece and troy but a war between achaeans (a greek tribe) and trojans (an other greek tribe)in the myth the trojans are descried as greeks. did homers trojan war exist Best answer: first of all let me tell you that the trojan war is a greek myth which describes a civil war it is not a war between greece and troy but a war between achaeans (a greek tribe) and trojans (an other greek tribe)in the myth the trojans are descried as greeks. did homers trojan war exist Best answer: first of all let me tell you that the trojan war is a greek myth which describes a civil war it is not a war between greece and troy but a war between achaeans (a greek tribe) and trojans (an other greek tribe)in the myth the trojans are descried as greeks. did homers trojan war exist Best answer: first of all let me tell you that the trojan war is a greek myth which describes a civil war it is not a war between greece and troy but a war between achaeans (a greek tribe) and trojans (an other greek tribe)in the myth the trojans are descried as greeks.
Did homers trojan war exist
Rated 5/5 based on 19 review

2018.